Santa Claus Secret: How to Talk About It With Your Kids

Santa Claus is a beloved figure who has been a part of the Christmas holiday season for centuries. He is known for his jolly personality and his generous spirit, delivering presents to children all over the world on Christmas Eve.

Key takeaways:
  • arrow-right
    Santa Claus creates Christmas magic around the holiday season, but many parents wonder what’s the best way to talk about Santa with their children.
  • arrow-right
    Many parents and experts have long debated the benefits and drawbacks to the Santa Claus myth. Proponents say that it adds an element of Christmas magic and wonder, while opponents argue that it equates to lying to children and even marks a betrayal of trust.
  • arrow-right
    There’s no one right time to reveal the Santa secret and tell children that he’s not real, but most kids will begin to notice things and come to the conclusion on their own.

Santa Claus is a staple in many family homes, especially those with young children. However, some parents may wonder if keeping up the myth of Santa has any downsides, or how they should go about talking with their children about Santa Claus. Below, you'll find some considerations and best practices for incorporating Santa into your family's Christmas celebrations.

The great Santa Claus debate

Many parents and experts have long debated the benefits and drawbacks to the Santa Claus myth, with solid arguments on both sides of the issue.

On one hand, some parents believe it is important to keep the spirit of Christmas alive by telling children about Santa Claus. They argue that Santa Claus adds an element of Christmas magic and wonder to the holiday season, making the holiday all the more special. Proponents point out that it can be a great way to teach children about the spirit of giving. They argue that it helps to instill a sense of kindness and generosity in children.

On the other hand, some parents are opposed to the idea of telling children about Santa Claus. They argue that it can be confusing for children to differentiate between what is real and what is not, and it can lead to disappointment when they find out the truth. Some even argue that maintaining the myth of Santa Claus equates to lying to children and even marks a betrayal of trust.

Regardless of where you stand, the decision around Santa Claus is a deeply personal one that must be decided from family to family. There is no one right answer here. Each parent has to decide for themselves what will work best for their family.

Ways to incorporate Santa into family traditions

There are many developmentally appropriate ways to incorporate Santa Clause into your family’s holiday traditions, even if you feel uncomfortable about lying to your children about his existence. Consider some of the ideas below.

Play pretend

If you view the Santa myth as lying to your children, consider telling your children about Santa and asking them if they’d like to pretend that he’s real. This can allow your children to participate in some of his Christmas magic while acknowledging that he’s make-believe.

Avoid using Santa as a threat

Avoid using Santa as a punishment or threat for good behavior. Although the song goes, “He knows if you’ve been bad or good” threatening children with poor quality presents isn’t a good way to encourage good behavior. Avoid saying things like “You better be good or Santa won’t bring you that toy you want.” Instead of tying their behavior to a tangible reward, teach your children to be kind to others and themselves because it’s the right thing to do. You can even talk about how to emulate Santa’s behavior as a positive lesson in giving back to others.

Give back to others

Use Santa as an opportunity to teach your kids to give back to others. This can be a great way to channel the Christmas spirit and foster a sense of generosity and kindness in your children. Talk to your children about how they can be like Santa by doing good deeds for others. Encourage them to think of creative ways to give to others, such as donating to a charity, helping a neighbor, or making a gift for someone special.

Revealing the Santa secret

Ultimately, there comes a time when every child learns that Santa isn’t real. Many parents want to know when they should tell their children about Santa Claus or if there’s an ideal age when they should have the conversation.

There is no single, definitive answer as to when the best time to tell children about Santa Claus is. Every child is unique and different, and the timing of when to share this information will depend on the individual child. Parents should take into account the maturity level, emotional state, and other factors when deciding when to tell their children the truth about Santa. Ultimately, the “right” time will be different for every child.

One of the best approaches to take is to follow your child’s lead. Your child will likely reach a point where they start to question whether Santa is real or not. Maybe they comment about how it seems unrealistic for Santa to visit every child in one night, or they notice that Santa uses the same wrapping paper as other gifts under the tree.

When your child notices these things or raises questions about Santa, use this as an opportunity to engage in a conversation with them about it. You might ask questions like:

  • “That’s interesting, what do you think about that?”
  • "What makes you ask about that?"
  • "What does Santa Claus mean to you?"

Ultimately, children are miniature detectives or scientists learning about the world through observation. If your child directly asks you if Santa is real or not, it’s best to tell them the truth. Once a child reaches a point where they ask about it, they probably have already come to the conclusion themselves.

Even after learning that Santa isn’t real, your child may decide to continue “believing” in Santa by carrying on the tradition and enjoying the Christmas magic, while still knowing that he’s not real. Your child might also enjoy helping younger siblings enjoy Santa and the Christmas spirit!


Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked