If you purchase via links on our site, we may receive commissions. However, our experts carefully research and evaluate each product or service, ensuring it meets our quality standards.

Best Medicare Advantage Plans in Illinois (IL) in 2024

Understanding the Medicare insurance plans offered can be overwhelming. This article will break down Medicare Advantage plans available in Illinois. These plans combine the essential benefits of Medicare Parts A and B and others like drug coverage, vision, dental, and hearing. We will highlight the best Illinois Medicare Advantage plans with the top coverage options.

Best Medicare Advantage plans in Illinois in 2024: shortlist

  1. Humana — best overall Medicare Advantage plan in Illinois
  2. AARP by United Healthcare — best access to benefits
  3. Blue Cross Blue Shield — best access to doctors

Best Medicare Advantage plans in Illinois: top providers reviewed

Choosing a health plan can feel overwhelming. We extensively researched the available Medicare Advantage plans in Illinois for 2024 and found the best ones. We have concluded our analysis, which ended with our top three picks for Medicare Advantage plans in Illinois which include Humana, AARP by United Healthcare, and Blue Cross Blue Shield.

1. Humana — best overall MA plan in Illinois

Provider overview
On CoverRight Website

As a widely offered MA plan in Illinois, Humana is highly rated by 90% of its members. It offers superior customer service, generous coverage, and premium benefits. Members of Humana benefit from routine dental, vision, hearing, and prescription drug coverage. In most parts of the country, including Illinois, Humana offers the SilverSneakers Fitness program at no additional cost.

2. AARP by United Healthcare — best access to benefits

Provider overview
On CoverRight Website

AARP by United Healthcare is greatly valued by beneficiaries who use Medicare Advantage programs in Chicago, IL, and the surrounding areas. Regardless of budget, there is something for everyone with United Healthcare. Beneficiaries have access to all the benefits covered under Medicare Parts A and B, including dental, vision, hearing, and lifestyle.

3. Blue Cross Blue Shield — best access to doctors

Provider overview
On CoverRight Website

Nothing is more convenient than having a health plan with a broad network because having access to all your doctors and specialists is extremely important. Blue Cross Blue Shield Medicare Advantage plans in Illinois offer comprehensive coverage in a wide network of providers and facilities, allowing most people to continue receiving care from the healthcare professionals they love the most.

There are 15 Blue Cross Blue Shield contracts for Medicare Advantage in Illinois. These generous contracts offer coverage packages that include dental, hearing, and vision services, leaving no doubt as to why many people choose this plan.

Comparing the top 3 Medicare Advantage plans in Illinois

This chart is an overview of how Illinois's top three Medicare Advantage plans in Illinois compare. Please note that each plan differs based on the offered zip code.

HumanaAARP by United HealthcareBlue Cross Blue Shield
Average monthly premium$27.74$27.60$27.73
Average in-network out-of-pocket max$4,500$3,600$4,500
Average annual drug deductible $143.82$150$143.73
Number of contracts available291815
Number of counties serviced1029297
Average CMS rating out of 53.8/54/53.68
NCQA (based on quality and member experience)
JD Powers (Overall Customer Satisfaction Index Ranking 2022)2nd4th6th

How we ranked the best Illinois Medicare Advantage plans

Our research considered multiple factors as we ranked the top three Illinois Medicare Advantage providers. These factors include the following:

  • Nationwide availability. If you choose to travel, your health plan must be supported and accepted regardless of where you go. When health plans are available across multiple states, there is a higher chance you’ll be in good hands when away from home.
  • Comprehensive coverage. As we ranked all the plans, we looked for more than the typical inpatient and outpatient services. We wanted to ensure beneficiaries of Medicare also chose a plan with great drug, dental, vision, and hearing coverage. Any health plans offering things like fitness programs made it to the short list of our favorites.
  • Value. We wanted to ensure the plans in question were affordable yet comprehensive in the services and coverage they provide.
  • Reviews. We also analyzed each health plan's reviews, testimonies, and rankings to understand how consumers feel about the plans they use.
  • Cost. Many Medicare beneficiaries are retired and have a fixed income. Because of this, cost is a consideration when choosing a Medicare Advantage plan.
  • CMS rating. CMS is an important rating by the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services. This rating stands for compliance with Medicare and ensures health plans are operating at the highest standards.

Medicare Advantage in Illinois: things to know

Illinois has a large population aged 65 and older, and the state is home to many Medicare beneficiaries and Medicare Advantage plans. While the specific coverage options vary from plan to plan, it is a standard expectation to have Medicare Parts A and B to be included with your Medicare Advantage plan in Illinois.

Prescription drug coverage varies with MA plans in Illinois but plenty of plans will provide the basics to offset the cost of your prescriptions. Here are some facts to be mindful of during the plan selection process:

  • In 2023, the average monthly premium for Medicare Advantage plans is $11.95
  • Illinois currently has 158 Medicare Advantage plans
  • As a Medicare-eligible beneficiary, you can access Medicare Advantage plans with a $0 premium.
  • Out-of-pocket costs range from $3,600 to $4,500, on average

What providers offer Medicare Advantage plans in Illinois

The list of Illinois Medicare Advantage plans is extensive, including 14 different carriers who offer many policies to choose from:

  • Aetna Medicare
  • Blue Cross Blue Shield of Illinois
  • Blue Cross Blue Shield of IL, NM
  • Cigna
  • Clear Springs Health
  • Devoted Health
  • Essence Healthcare
  • Health Alliance Medicare
  • HealthPartners UnityPoint Health
  • Humana
  • Medica
  • Medical Associates Health Plan
  • Molina Healthcare of Illinois
  • Quarts Medicare Advantage

5-Star Medicare Advantage plans in Illinois

Overall, Illinois has a nice selection of Medicare Advantage programs in Chicago as well as other areas throughout the state. The highest 5-star rated Medicare Advantage plans are offered by the following insurance carriers:

  • Essence Healthcare
  • Humana
  • Health Partners
  • United Healthcare

Medicare Advantage plans in Illinois: comparing different counties

Medicare Advantage plans differ nationwide and within any given state based on the county and zip code. We collected data on some counties that offer Medicare Advantage in Illinois to provide a snapshot of the type of availability, monthly premiums, and out-of-pocket maximums to expect.

Cook CountyMclean CountyMarshall County
Number of residents enrolled in a plan361,24012,4651,039
Number of plan contracts available321164155
Number of plan contracts utilized502217
Number of health insurance companies providing plans1188
Health insurance companies providing plansAetna Medicare Blue Cross Blue Shield of IL, NM Blue Cross Blue Shield of Illinois Cigna Clear Spring Health Devoted Health Humana Molina Healthcare of Illinois UnitedHealthcare Wellcare Wellcare by AllwellAetna Blue Cross Blue Shield of IL, NM Health Alliance Medicare Humana Molina Healthcare of Illinois UnitedHealthcare Wellcare WellFirst HealthAetna Medicare Blue Cross Blue Shield of IL, NM Health Alliance Medicare Humana Molina Healthcare of Illinois UnitedHealthcare WellFirst Health
Average monthly premium of these plans$20.73$35.74$36.59
Average monthly out-of-pocket maximum of these plans$3,967.18$4,419.74$4,377.03

What are the eligibility requirements for a Medicare Advantage plan in Illinois?

Some of the requirements you must meet to enroll into a Medicare Advantage in Illinois plan include:

  • Enrolled in Medicare Parts A and B. Before you qualify for a Medicare Advantage plan, you must first qualify and be enrolled in Medicare Part A and Part B.
  • Residency. It is also required that you live within the plan’s service area. Not all Medicare Advantage plans in Illinois are as encompassing as the three we’ve shortlisted. However, if you choose one of the three in this review, you will have greater flexibility in your place of residency.
  • Not having end-stage renal disease. Most Medicare beneficiaries who have end-stage renal disease are qualified for Original Medicare only. This is due to the extent of services the beneficiary will require for their needs.
  • Eligibility for Medicare due to age or disability. It is also important to qualify for Medicare. In other words, the individual must be 65, have a qualified special enrollment period opportunity, or have a qualifying disability and receive Social Security Disability Insurance (SSDI) for more than 24 months.
  • Enrolling during initial enrollment or the annual election period. Medicare beneficiaries can choose a Medicare Advantage plan during their initial enrollment period. This is when individuals first become qualified for Medicare. This enrollment period begins three months before they turn 65 and ends three months after. If a beneficiary qualifies for Medicare after they stop working after age 65, they can still enroll in a Medicare Advantage plan. Beneficiaries also have the option to choose or change their Medicare Advantage plan on an annual basis during the open enrollment season. This annual period runs from October 15 to December 7.

Choosing the best Medicare Advantage plan in Illinois

As you make your choice of an Illinois Medicare Advantage plan, ask yourself the following questions about your healthcare needs:

  • What hospitals accept the plan you’re considering?
  • Will your doctor be an in-network provider for this plan?
  • Does the plan offer prescription drug coverage for your medications?
  • Are preventative services offered?
  • Can you get dental, hearing, vision services?
  • What addition perks do they offer? (Such as fitness, wellness)
  • Can you afford the monthly premiums, deductible, and out-of-pocket expenses?

As you answer these questions about health plans, you can narrow your search more seamlessly of the best advantage programs in Chicago, IL. Whether you choose Humana, AARP by United Healthcare, Blue Cross Blue Shield, or another plan, this article can guide you and help you make the best decision for your healthcare.


Leave a reply

Your email will not be published. All fields are required.