Electroconvulsive Therapy (ECT): Safe Mental Health Treatment

When depression is severe and medications aren’t helping, there is another option. Electroconvulsive therapy (ECT) is an effective treatment for people with debilitating mental health problems. ECT is considered the best treatment available for severe depression, offering lifesaving, long-term treatment.

Key takeaways:
  • arrow-right
    ECT is a safe and effective treatment for major psychiatric disorders.
  • arrow-right
    Treatments are done by a psychiatrist, anesthesiologist, and treatment nurse and must be performed in a hospital or day surgery center.
  • arrow-right
    The ECT treatment itself is quick, with a low-impulse electric shock to the brain, inducing a seizure lasting 30–90 seconds.
  • arrow-right
    Treatments are repetitive, usually starting at 3 times a week for 2 weeks, then tapering off, with ongoing maintenance if/when (either one) needed.
  • arrow-right
    There is a shortage of treatment facilities nationwide, especially in rural areas, and travel is often an issue.

The history of electroconvulsive treatment

ECT treatment began in the mid-1930s and has been used since then to treat psychosis, severe depression, and debilitating anxiety. A shock wave is administered to certain areas in the brain and essentially “re-boots” the neurotransmitters, creating new thought pathways and relief for mental health challenges.

The idea for this treatment came about when a doctor noticed that a psychotic patient with epilepsy would have a change in mood and behavior after experiencing a seizure. In 1938, Italian neurologist, Ugo Cerletti, and his psychiatrist colleague, Lucino Bini, built the first ECT device. It delivered electrical impulses to the frontal lobe of the brain to cause a seizure. The treatment was a great success, alleviating the psychotic symptoms of their schizophrenic patient, and they were nominated for the Nobel Prize in Medicine. By the early 1940s, ECT treatment was used in every major city worldwide, effectively treating people with severe mental health disorders.

What conditions does ECT treat?

  • Severe depression
  • Suicidal ideation
  • Schizophrenia
  • Bipolar disorder in the manic phase
  • Catatonia

Patients with hard-to-treat psychiatric conditions that are unable to take or aren’t responding to psychiatric medicines are referred by their physician or psychiatrist to a neuropsychiatric treatment center. Psychiatrists specializing in ECT treatment evaluate the patient and ensure that a work-up, including a physical exam, EKG, chest x-ray, and blood work, is completed before treatment.

ECT is a safe and lifesaving treatment for people with debilitating psychiatric symptoms; it’s the most effective acute treatment for depression when medication alone isn’t enough. However, it isn’t a cure and is often needed long-term to control the ongoing symptoms of depression, anxiety, and psychosis.

Today’s ECT is a state-of-the-art therapy

The advent of pre-medicating patients with anesthesia and muscle relaxants has brought about “modified treatment;” a much easier and safer way to receive electro-convulsive therapy. This type of modern treatment requires an anesthesiologist, psychiatrist, and nurse to be present during the procedure. A general anesthetic and muscle relaxer is given by IV injection, which keeps the patient asleep and relaxed during treatment. Once asleep, a low voltage of electricity is delivered to the brain for 30–90 seconds, inducing a seizure. After therapy is completed, the patient is observed in the recovery room for 20–30 minutes, and once awake, they are given something to eat and drink, then discharged home.

On the day of treatment, patients aren’t able to drive themselves, since they receive a general anesthetic. They may have short-term memory loss and confusion from the medications but can return to normal activities in a day or so. Many people live active, independent lives while receiving ECT treatment.

What happens to the brain during ECT

Although the actions of the electrical current on the brain aren’t fully understood, the chemical changes that occur are known to positively affect the debilitating symptoms of mental illness. The electrical impulses cause a burst of neurons to fire rapidly, restructuring neuropathways, and essentially re-booting the brain. Thought patterns are altered and negative symptoms are lessened or removed by the treatment.

MRI imaging has shown that brain function increases after continued ECT treatment and positively affects memory. State-of-the-art modified ECT therapy causes changes in the brain that stabilize mood, decreasing symptoms of depression. Studies support the safety of continual treatment in aging adults and disprove brain impairment, dementia, and long-term memory loss as side effects of treatment.

The ECT treatment course

ECT starts with an “index course”: 3 treatments a week for 2 weeks totaling 6–12 treatments, then decreasing slowly to once a week for a month. The psychiatrist and patient determine the frequency of ongoing ECT needed. It isn’t a cure; symptoms will reoccur and continual treatment is commonly needed. It’s a matter of how long the patient can go without returning symptoms. Many people have monthly treatment regimens for their lifetime.

ECT has provided remarkable results for people who have suffered untreatable symptoms from depression, schizophrenia, and bipolar disorder. The old opinion of shock therapy is no longer accurate; it’s a safe and effective treatment that not only changes but saves lives. Dr. Leigh Brown, DO, an ECT provider at Seattle NTC, states, “ECT is a highly effective treatment for depression, and should not be thought of as a ‘last resort.’”

Sadly, ECT treatment facilities are lacking in rural areas, and traveling for treatment is a major hurdle for many people. More psychiatrists are needed to develop treatment programs in smaller, community hospitals.

The stigma surrounding mental illness and ECT treatment is outdated and inaccurate. As the general public and medical professionals educate themselves about the safety and efficacy of today's modified ECT treatment, mental health care will improve nationwide.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked  

Comments

Cheryl Prax Cheryl Prax
prefix 13 days ago
ECT gives permanent brain damage. Any immediate effect is due to concussion. A temporary euphoria which fades after 4 - 6 weeks and the patient goes back to how they were plus they now have brain damage. People can forget their education and many years of their past life. They can have cognitive deficits and be unable to make new memories. ECT machines have never been tested for safety on humans by the machine manufacturers, the FDA (US) or the MHRA (UK).
The manufacturers of Thymatron ECT machines, Somatics, were recently forced to add 'Permanent brain damage' to their list of 'side effects' after they were sued (and settled out of court) by damaged patients
Healthnews Team Healthnews Team
prefix 10 days ago
The number of positive outcomes from ECT treatment has made it the number one treatment available for severe depression. It is also used to treat severe psychosis, debilitating anxiety, suicidal ideology and catatonia effectively.

Is it a treatment for able minded people. Absolutely not. Mildly even moderately mental instability is not indicative for treatment.

Yes, there are reports of people severely affected by the treatment. It is invasive and there are risks. Sadly some people have serious long term memory loss and there are reports of brain damage.

The people undergoing this treatment are in dire mental health situations. They can’t function independently, their quality of life severely impaired and ECT is a hopeful treatment for their situation.

When searching the internet, negative responses to ECT can be found. Has been memory loss, and articles written about individuals who have suffered amnesia, reduction in IQ, and difficulty with assimilation of new information has been reported by individuals. The FDA has approved and set guidelines for the operation of ECT machinery in the US. Patients are evaluated prior to each treatment and symptoms assessed and graded.

Individuals and families are finding positive response from the treatment, and it does usually need to be repeated, ongoing, because it can’t cure the mental illness. The patients continue treatment, the benefits outweigh side effects, and many people experience very little.